I've not seen the line drawn there before

[john_amend_all]

Ever since the 2005 revival, and probably before, there's been a fairly standard template for an article about Doctor Who which goes: "Introducing the new companion, who's completely different from all the helpless screamers who came before her." Or, retrospectively, "X was a radical introduction as companion, so different from all the helpless screamers etc."

I think today's the first time I've seen the division between 'helpless screamer' and 'competent companion' placed as late as between Rose and Martha. I mean, say what you like about Rose (and I have) I'm finding it very difficult to picture her as 'hysterically screaming at every threat'.

(And another demerit to the article's author for capitalising the Doctor's "The" like it's a royal pronoun).

Comments

[liadt]

I read the article and wondered if AI was used in the writing.

[john_amend_all]

I wondered that too — it has that faintly sleazy air of self-confidence combined with a cavalier disregard for actual facts.